Bellingham risks England exile if he rejects Tuchel’s team-first approach

Tuchel's Challenge: Building Unity in England’s Squad

Thomas Tuchel once stood on the touchline at Anfield, bewildered as his Paris Saint-Germain players failed to match the intensity of Jürgen Klopp’s Liverpool. “Guys, what is this?” he asked, but his words fell on deaf ears. The squad, filled with individuals who placed personal ambitions above collective effort, lacked the discipline Tuchel demanded.

Commitment? Defensive work? Not for them. Too many preferred to play their own way, ultimately wearing Tuchel down. The German manager thrives on structure, identity, and hard work. At PSG, however, he witnessed how individualism can derail a team. How could he impose his philosophy when even a sideways glance between teammates sparked tension?

This brings us to England, celebrity culture, and the importance of unity. Steven Gerrard recently highlighted the flaws of the “egotistical losers” from England’s past—where club rivalries and an obsession with star players held the national team back. It’s no surprise that Tuchel, unfazed by ruffling feathers, is determined to build something different as he prepares England for next summer’s World Cup.

“We are building the best team” has been Tuchel’s consistent message. His decision to exclude Jude Bellingham, Jack Grealish, and Phil Foden has not wavered. “The radical statement is that we don’t collect the most talented players,” Tuchel said before England’s win over Wales. “We collect those who create cohesion and make the best team.”

Tuchel’s career offers insights into his approach with Bellingham. At PSG, having Neymar, Kylian Mbappé, and Edinson Cavani didn’t translate to Champions League success. At Bayern Munich, clashes with key players arose. Yet at Chelsea, his greatest achievement—winning the 2021 Champions League—came with a resilient, defensively astute team. N’Golo Kanté was instrumental, alongside professionals like Thiago Silva and the relentless Mason Mount.

Chelsea were disciplined and unyielding. Now, Tuchel aims to forge the same unity with England. He dismissed concerns that omitting his most creative players before the Wales match was a risk—and was vindicated when Morgan Rogers, Ollie Watkins, and Bukayo Saka tore through the opposition in a dominant first half.

Tuchel’s England is taking shape. Overlapping full-backs, pace on the wings (crucial for Harry Kane’s success at the World Cup), and a balanced midfield with Declan Rice and Elliot Anderson point to progress. “We are getting there,” Tuchel said after the 3-0 win. “In Serbia, it looked like club football, and today…”

The experiment continues, but the vision is clear.