"Five key questions for Angela Rayner about her Hove property"

1. Where Does She Reside?

The individual in question divides her time among three properties: a home in Ashton-under-Lyne, an apartment in Admiralty House on Whitehall provided as part of her role, and a recently purchased flat in Hove.

When she bought the Hove property in May, she declared it as her sole residence, reducing the stamp duty payment to an estimated £30,000 rather than the higher £70,000 rate. However, she had previously registered her Ashton property as her main residence, allowing her to avoid approximately £2,000 in annual council tax on the London residence.

The Ashton home has since been placed in a trust, removing her name from the deeds and facilitating the purchase of the Hove flat. Despite this, she continues to spend significant time there, as her children live there, and it is the only property located within her constituency.

2. Why Was the Ashton Home Placed in a Trust?

Reports revealed that the Greater Manchester property was partially placed in a trust in 2023 before being fully transferred this year. The trust was managed by a law firm specializing in wealth management services.

Some have speculated that the move was intended to reduce inheritance tax liability for her children. However, tax experts point out that if she lives there at the time of her death, inheritance tax would still apply regardless of the trust. Other reasons for the arrangement may include preventing children from selling their share without mutual consent.

Notably, the property's value was listed at £650,000 when placed in the trust. Had it been valued even slightly higher, an immediate inheritance tax charge would have applied.

3. Have Any Tax Laws Been Broken?

Most experts, including those close to her, agree that no explicit rules were violated. It is legally permissible to declare different properties as primary residences for council tax and stamp duty purposes.

Critics argue that the situation highlights a loophole that has been utilized effectively. One tax professional suggested greater coordination between tax authorities and local councils to ensure consistency in property tax assessments.

However, some experts believe tax investigators could still question whether the higher stamp duty rate should have applied to the Hove purchase. Removing one’s name from a deed may not suffice if the individual continues to reside in that property, potentially making the new acquisition liable for additional stamp duty.

4. Why the Complex Arrangements?

Supporters claim that personal circumstances contribute to the complexity of her financial arrangements. Having children plays a role in her living situation.