Keir Starmer’s attempts to overhaul the United Kingdom’s ties with the European Union are being criticised for a lack of “direction, definition and drive”, the House of Commons foreign affairs committee said.
The committee’s report, drawn from months of testimony from specialists, noted that the Lancaster House summit between the UK and the EU in May last year had “considerably improved the overall political relationship” after a period of intense criticism of Brussels by Conservative ministers.
Nevertheless, the document concluded that the United Kingdom “does not have clear strategic priorities”, a shortfall that creates “the impression that the EU has made more tangible progress on its most urgent demands than the UK”.
Emily Thornberry, Labour MP and chair of the committee, said: “Unfortunately we found that, despite advances in some fields, the government’s reset is stalling, hampered by an absence of direction, definition and drive. It feels as if we are on a journey without a clear destination.
“In many areas the government has failed to set timetables, milestones or priorities, and it does not appear to possess an ambitious, strategic vision for the UK’s new relationship with the EU.”
The report warned that unless the government establishes a framework and a transparent vision with concrete objectives, it will repeat “these mistakes” when it enters the second round of talks following a further bilateral summit scheduled for early July.
Last May’s summit was described as a “historic” occasion and produced a formal accord to upgrade the Brexit settlement concluded under Boris Johnson, with aims that included a youth‑mobility scheme, re‑entry into the Erasmus student programme and an agricultural pact to ease barriers for food exporters.
To date the only element that has been finalised is the Erasmus arrangement; several crucial topics – regulation of chemicals, mutual recognition of standards, professional qualification equivalence and concessions for touring musicians – remain off the negotiating table.
The committee noted that progress “has been hindered by the EU’s recent shift of the goalposts, demanding a financial contribution to the economic development of lower‑income EU states, a request absent from last year’s summit”.
It also criticised what it called an “exorbitant” €2 billion (£1.7 billion) price tag for the UK’s participation in the first phase of the EU’s €150 billion Security Action for Europe (SAFE) defence‑procurement programme.
While welcoming the UK‑EU security and defence partnership, the report urged both parties and individual member states “to move further and faster”.
Sources indicate the United Kingdom is negotiating a deal on a second potential fund to assist Ukraine with military equipment and to address budgetary issues such as salaries for teachers, doctors and other public servants.
The €90 billion fund would be sourced from loans raised on the basis of the EU’s AAA credit rating and would be repaid by Russia through reparations or frozen assets.
The UK is reportedly ready to provide several hundred million pounds to help cover the interest on the loan in return for arms contracts for British firms.
Read next
New dual‑national rules leave more British teens stranded overseas
Two more British teenagers have found themselves unable to return to the United Kingdom because of the Home Office’s new border regulations for dual nationals.
Their situations were reported only hours after a 16‑year‑old British schoolgirl was prevented from boarding a flight in Denmark for the UK
Health Department withdraws statement that sunbeds are as harmful as smoking
The Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) has withdrawn a misleading statement that sunbeds pose a cancer risk comparable to smoking.
In January, officials announced tighter regulations for sunbeds, wrongly asserting they were “as dangerous as smoking”. The claim was echoed in social‑media posts from the health secretary
Should the UK admit its military rhetoric outpaces its actual capabilities?
It will have been more than three weeks since the United States and Israel first struck Iran when the first British warship finally reached the waters off Cyprus, a delayed defensive move that has underscored the shortage of military capability available to the United Kingdom.
In name, HMS Dragon was