One of Keir Starmer’s senior ministers has acknowledged that the government’s retreat on welfare reforms will come with financial consequences, as a prominent economic research group suggested new tax increases may now be more probable.
Pat McFadden, the chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster, supported Starmer and Liz Kendall, the work and pensions secretary, after a key provision was dropped from the government’s welfare legislation to secure its passage through the first Commons vote.
“Above all, we stand together,” McFadden stated in an interview with BBC Radio 4’s *Today* when questioned about Kendall’s position following the decision to abandon proposed reductions to personal independence payments (Pip) to prevent a potential defeat.
However, with projected annual savings of £5 billion from Pip adjustments now off the table, McFadden admitted this would impact budget preparations for the autumn.
“You cannot allocate the same funds twice,” he said. “I recognize there is a financial impact from yesterday’s decision, but everything will be considered when the budget is finalized.”
The universal credit and personal independence payment bill passed its second reading on Tuesday evening by 335 votes to 260, a majority of 75.
Forty-nine Labour MPs opposed the legislation—more than three times the number who rebelled last month when 16 voted against the government on amendments to the planning and infrastructure bill.
Helen Miller, the director of the Institute for Fiscal Studies, noted that the absence of savings from Pip revisions makes tax increases “more likely” in the upcoming budget, warning that Chancellor Rachel Reeves now has “very little flexibility.”
The current version of the welfare bill would generate no savings, Miller told *Today*: “By the end of this parliamentary term, the government will have saved nothing.”
With the £5 billion no longer available, along with an additional £1 billion lost due to the recent reversal on winter fuel payments, much of Reeves’s fiscal margin has disappeared, Miller added, especially if growth projections are revised downward.
Read next
Labour faces key challenge as voting begins in England, Scotland and Wales
Polling has opened across England, Scotland and Wales in a series of local, mayoral and parliamentary contests – the biggest electoral test Keir Starmer and the Labour government have faced since the 2024 general election.
As millions of people across Great Britain go to the polls on Thursday, party leaders are
Andy Burnham's Green Party Appearance Fuels Labour Backlash
Andy Burnham’s choice to join a progressive rally featuring leading Green and Liberal Democrat figures has provoked criticism from certain Labour MPs, who claim he is weakening their local election message.
The Greater Manchester mayor, regarded as one of the leading contenders to challenge Keir Starmer for the Labour
Scottish mother stranded abroad after newborn breaches UK dual citizenship rules
A British woman from Aberdeen has been stranded abroad after her 11‑month‑old baby was prevented from boarding a flight because of new rules regarding dual nationals.
Sarah Schloegl was refused board on a Ryanair flight from Alicante last week after she went to Spain for a short break