Zohran Mamdani’s unexpected victory in New York’s mayoral primary reflects the stark divisions in the city—and the nation. On one side, a young progressive candidate overcame the entrenched political establishment, despite its vast resources and influential backers. On the other, a wave of racism and anti-Muslim sentiment erupted, with some portraying his success as an extremist takeover, driven by unfounded fears of radical ideology.
In the aftermath of Mamdani’s win, hostility toward Muslims surged, revealing an unsettling tolerance for bigotry. While little shocks the U.S. these days, the intensity of the backlash exposed deep-seated prejudice.
Political figures, former officials, and social media personalities amplified false narratives, imagining absurd scenarios of ideological domination. Some described his win as a consequence of unchecked immigration, while others hurled degrading insults, questioning his loyalty and demanding his removal from office.
The reaction has been so extreme that even inflammatory rhetoric from polarizing figures appears mild in comparison. Some responses border on parody—yet they are tragically real. The notion that Mamdani, known for his earnest demeanor, is some extremist threat is absurd enough to be laughable—but the persistence of such beliefs reveals a darker reality.
Years later, it remains astonishing how public Muslim figures provoke such irrational fear—and how easily anti-Muslim hatred is dismissed. Prominent leaders in Mamdani’s own party have remained silent, and those spreading falsehoods face no repercussions. When prejudice becomes normalized, its harm goes unchallenged.
The indifference to attacks on Mamdani stems not just from his faith but also from his politics. His real “offense” is not his background but his critique of mainstream economic policies and foreign affairs. His progressive stance—on taxes, housing, and U.S. support for conflict—has made him a target, fueling resistance from those invested in the status quo.
The response to his campaign underscores deeper tensions, revealing both the potential for change and the resistance it provokes.
Read next
"Reject authoritarianism – Reform and the far right can be halted, says Gordon Brown"
Nigel Farage describes his Reform UK party as a distinctive force that has surged onto the global scene, its rapid ascent framed as an unparalleled political shift. Yet this week, across Europe’s largest nations and from India and Thailand to the US and Argentina, similar hard-right movements—opposing immigration
"Embracing solo travel: Women break tradition to holiday alone"
A few weeks ago, I received an invitation for a press trip I would never consider. It involved a long flight and centered around fitness, meaning it would require a lot of physical activity and early mornings. Even if I were fond of such things, spending a week with others
"Tony Blair’s relentless penchant for meddling in the Middle East persists"
“There are two types of politician,” Tony Blair noted in 2012. “Those who shape reality and those who manage it.” He argued that while postwar politics mostly involved steady governance, the changing world demanded more imagination, “both in economic and international affairs.” Only a certain kind of forward-thinking leader, he