Five days after losing the first round of the Brazilian presidential election, left-wing President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva experienced a nearly 24-hour disruption in his ability to promote posts on Instagram, while his rival, far-right Senator Flávio Bolsonaro, did not face such issues.
Lula's legal team included this incident in a dossier presented to the electoral court and international observers as evidence that Meta, Instagram's parent company, was allegedly intervening in Brazil's election in favor of Bolsonaro. This claim was supported by numerous reports from Lula's supporters who noted content removal or restricted reach on social media platforms in Brazil. Additionally, about a dozen watchdogs and research organizations released reports highlighting possible signs of Meta's bias towards Bolsonaro's campaign.
Meta refuted these allegations as "false and unfounded," attributing the issues to "technical incidents" affecting various political campaigns. Amidst this controversy, which intensified the electoral competition just before the upcoming runoff, the electoral court instructed Meta to ensure no unequal treatment of the candidates.
Justice Marco Aurélio Bellizze, late last week, found no proof of intentional misconduct by Meta, though he mandated the company to demonstrate that the issues affecting Lula had been resolved and would not recur. After Meta's initial response failed to satisfy Bellizze, he granted the company an additional 24 hours. On Tuesday, Meta denied any bias and stated it had implemented human oversight to prevent automated restrictions.
Meta's oversight board expressed concern over recurring enforcement failures in its election integrity measures, referencing both the Brazilian election and an unrelated incident in the U.S. where an anti-fraud system erroneously suspended an account during voter encouragement demonstrations. The board noted a pattern in Brazil where Meta's policies were over-enforced against Lula's campaign accounts on September 23, when a temporary disablement occurred due to a misclassified ad.
João Victor Archegas from the Institute for Technology and Society highlighted the challenge of proving Meta's interference due to restricted access to the company's internal data, limiting external scrutiny. Platforms like Google and TikTok have banned political ads in this election, leaving Meta as a primary channel for digital campaigning, significantly boosting its revenue.
A report by watchdog CTRL+Z documented 1,121 instances of content suppression affecting mainly left-wing profiles. Meanwhile, Media outlets showcased an experiment where Meta's AI assistant generated artwork for Flávio Bolsonaro but initially failed for Lula, which the company attributed to a safeguard gap.
Many Lula supporters suspected Meta of acting on behalf of U.S. President Donald Trump, who has connections to the Bolsonaro family, though no evidence was provided. Lula's legal team suggested Meta was aligned with Trump's administration and exerting external pressure on Brazilian voters.
Lula's lawyers argued that the temporary Instagram issue created an unfair advantage for Bolsonaro. Meta clarified that the outage affected new posts only, was a global incident impacting many advertisers, and insisted on consistent rule application across all political entities.
NetLab, a research group at the Federal University of Rio de Janeiro, found at least 1,600 election ads boosted from outside Brazil, violating local laws. Despite not finding political bias, they criticized Meta's inability to comply with electoral regulations, potentially undermining the electoral process. On election eve, NetLab identified misleading ads falsely promoting online voting options.
Read next
What Lies Ahead for France Post-Riots? Europe Columnists Weigh In
After weeks of protests and a weekend of riots resulting in a town hall set ablaze, over 2,000 shops looted, 2,300 arrests, and 1,000 police officers injured, the repercussions for France—both societal and economic—continue to unfold. Allegations of police brutality have emerged, causing distress among
Putin Commands Release of Detained American Amid Ukraine Talks with Trump Envoy
Vladimir Putin ordered the release of an American from a Russian jail during discussions with Donald Trump's envoy, Steve Witkoff, in St. Petersburg on Wednesday. The meeting focused on efforts to end the conflict in Ukraine, highlighting the strengthening ties between Moscow and Washington.
Trump had requested Putin
In the dark, YouTubers oversee a stranded shark in a South Korean canal.
In South Korea, a group known as jagyeongdan, reminiscent of a neighborhood watch, has taken it upon themselves to protect a stranded shark named Bukang-i in Busan's harbor. Since becoming trapped in a city canal on September 18, Bukang-i, a 3-meter-long endangered dusky shark,