The relatives of a man who lost his retirement savings after becoming entangled in the Norton Motorcycles pension scheme fraud are set to forfeit nearly half of their compensation due to an obscure tax regulation.
After a prolonged effort to secure payment from the Fraud Compensation Fund (FCF), Robert Dewar’s pension was only reimbursed in 2024, five years after his death at age 64.
His widow, Susan, had anticipated inheriting the pension without tax obligations, as is customary when a spouse passes away before turning 75. However, a little-known provision in tax rules dictates that the delayed transfer of the £114,000 owed will now incur a levy, leaving her with an estimated tax bill of around £50,000.
The couple’s daughter, Sally Holmes, stated: “Once my father transferred his pension—what was then considered a legitimate arrangement—we were powerless to reverse the situation. Our sole recourse was through the Fraud Compensation Fund, which took years to resolve, ensuring the tax charge. The system’s setup made this outcome unavoidable.”
The tax imposition adds further distress to a family that emerged as prominent advocates during the lengthy fight for victim restitution.
The controversy originated in 2012 and 2013 when over 200 individuals were deceived into moving roughly £11.5 million from their retirement plans under a so-called pension liberation scam.
Most of these funds were funneled into three Norton pension schemes where the firm’s ex-owner, Stuart Garner, served as a trustee. The money later disappeared after being invested into the historic motorcycle company, which traces its roots to the 1800s and once counted figures like revolutionary Ernesto “Che” Guevara and actor Keanu Reeves among its enthusiasts.
Garner admitted in 2022 to unlawfully using millions from pension savings to finance his ventures. He received an eight-month suspended prison sentence, though he has maintained that he, too, fell prey to the original fraud.
The downfall marked a stark reversal for the businessman, who had leveraged Norton’s prestige for a brief appearance in the 2015 James Bond film *Spectre* and accompanied a trade delegation to China aboard then-Prime Minister Theresa May’s plane.
Last year, the FCF distributed £9.4 million to the three collapsed pension funds—more than a decade after victims believed their life savings had been lost.
A representative for tax authorities said: “We recognize the difficulty in these cases and extend our sympathies to those involved. For deaths occurring before age 75, a pension lump sum is tax-free only if paid within two years of the scheme’s notification of death.”
Read next
Rich Britons fleeing Gulf conflict skip the UK to dodge tax bills
Wealthy Britons escaping conflict in the Gulf are looking for refuge in places such as Ireland and France to sidestep large tax charges at home.
Facing possible claims from HM Revenue and Customs, high‑net‑worth individuals who have been residing in the United Arab Emirates and nearby states hope
Home Office reverses policy, allowing certain dual nationals to enter the UK with an EU passport.
British dual nationals who are EU citizens with post‑Brexit settlement status in the UK will no longer need a British passport to re‑enter the country, the Home Office announced, overturning its earlier dual‑national border policy.
The amendment, which critics described as “buried” on a government website, appears
Hereditary Lords set to lose their seats in the House of Lords
Hereditary titles will be ended before the forthcoming monarch’s address after an agreement was reached to award life peerages to certain Conservatives and cross‑benchers who would otherwise lose their places.
On Tuesday night the upper chamber approved the final version of the House of Lords (hereditary peers) Bill,