For Aiden Robertson, a 35-year-old consultant from Burnley, Labour’s first year in office has been "deeply disappointing."
He described the year as marked by "poor communication, unclear goals, and no real direction," arguing the party had focused too much on appealing to voters who would never support them.
"It just feels like more of the same Conservative policies. As someone who’s voted Labour in every election since 2010, this is the first time I’ve questioned my support," he said.
Robertson was among hundreds who shared their views on Keir Starmer’s first year in power with *CuriosityNews*.
The responses—many of them highly critical—highlighted the government’s struggle to gain public approval. Many on the left called the prime minister’s approach a "betrayal" of Labour’s traditional values, while others expressed frustration over the lack of major reforms despite the party’s parliamentary majority.
Some retirees, caregivers, and welfare recipients called for higher taxes to improve public services and social welfare. Meanwhile, overburdened workers, middle-class professionals, and business owners questioned why their incomes were taxed heavily while wealth remained under-taxed, criticizing a perceived lack of economic stability.
Progressive voters raised concerns over Labour’s handling of international relations, welfare reform, and its response to climate change, housing, and education. Others believed immigration—a top issue for many—was not being controlled effectively.
Those who viewed the government positively cited the return of "competent leadership," praising welfare reform efforts, rail nationalization, Starmer’s foreign policy decisions—such as addressing trade tariffs—resolved public sector strikes, and increased defense spending.
Some argued that harsh media coverage was unfairly damaging the new administration.
Mary, a 61-year-old council employee from near Hull, said the government had faced unwarranted criticism.
"I support the changes to farm taxes and winter fuel payments," she said. "I live in an affluent area and know many who don’t need the extra support. Benefits should be means-tested, not given out indiscriminately."
Read next
Badenoch returns to Conservative conference, markedly stronger than a year ago
A year ago, Tory MPs feared a fresh leadership revolt against Kemi Badenoch as Tories hit historic 14-16% support; November, after 12 months, was hushed: decisive challenge month. Yet, despite poor polls, “Keminisation” saw her impose style and authority.
More in Common’s Luke Tryl, director, said Badenoch holds
UK sanctions plan on illegal Israeli settlements faces criticism from US, Israel and British MPs
Today, with the agreement of Prime Minister Netanyahu, Israeli officials announced a series of countermeasures in response to new sanctions declared by the British foreign secretary of the Labour government, following a sequence of anti-Israel decisions by the same administration.
The accusations leveled today by the Labour foreign secretary,
UK announces trade ban on Israeli settlements as tougher stance
Ed Miliband will announce a broad reset of the UK’s relations with Israel on Tuesday, pledging a more active stance in support of the Palestinian cause. In an intervention drawing fierce criticism from the US and Israel, the foreign secretary will impose a ban on trade in goods and